By Monday morning after the Super Bowl, marketing teams are either celebrating or asking what went wrong. Some watch their ad take off on social media. Others refresh the feed and see little movement. But is virality the right measure?
Nobody in the room can say why one ad resonated while another did not, though every team has a theory. Super Bowl advertising effectiveness depends on whether the ad moved people: whether it changed how they see the brand and whether it got them to take action.
MarketCast measured the 68 national ads that aired in Super Bowl LX. Now you can test your instincts: pick the winners in five matchups and see how they compare. Play the game.
The data below shows why liked, remembered and worked are three different answers.
The stakes are higher this year. Super Bowl LX drew 125 million viewers, within about 1% of last year. Only 20% of viewers could recall both the ad and the brand the next day, the lowest breakthrough in six years and down from 28% in 2021. When breaking through is that hard, applause is an expensive thing to mistake for results.
Why “liked it” wins the meeting
Likeability, views and social buzz are visible by Monday. They are easy to screenshot and easy to defend, so they get used as proof. They record how people felt in the moment. What the ad did to viewers, and to the brand, shows up in other measures.
Lay’s shows how little buzz can say. Social conversation around the brand was 95% neutral, mostly contest entries from its sweepstakes. Read that conversation alone and Lay’s reads as flat. Measured across creative strength, memory and brand credit, Lay’s held two of the top three spots among 68 national ads.
What works in Super Bowl advertising: three questions to ask before you pick
The best Super Bowl ads of LX each won a different question. Liked, remembered and credited are separate, and a strong ad can win any of them. Use them as your scorecard in the game.
Did people like it? Lay’s “Last Harvest,” a family-farm story, ranked first of 68 on likeability and third overall. Its Brand Ad Appeal, which measures net positive memory of the ad, reached 31% against a Super Bowl norm of 10%.
Did it stick? Budweiser’s “American Icons” ranked first on breakthrough, with an index of 235 against an average of 100. Its Brand Ad Appeal hit 35%. The spot was built on distinctive brand assets, and viewers kept both the story and the brand.
Did the brand get the credit? Lay’s “72 Hour Challenge” ranked first on brand linkage and second overall. Levi’s reached a brand linkage index of 145 by putting its iconic jeans in shot throughout the spot. Kinder Bueno posted a 130 in its Super Bowl debut by weaving its name into the storyline and saying it ten times in 30 seconds.
The same night, several well-liked spots lost the brand at the finish. Viewers remembered the story and could not say who it was for.
What a full picture requires
You need two reads. One is what stuck: how many viewers remembered the ad, and how many connected it to the brand. The other is what the ad could do: how engaging the creative was and how clearly it communicated.
Each read has blind spots on its own. Together they show where an ad is strong and where it leaks, and the places where the two disagree are where the useful decisions sit.
When they agree, you can see it clearly. Xfinity’s “Jurassic Park…Works” scored 153 on engagement against a norm of 138, scored 5.42 on clarity against a norm of 5.08, and posted an ad memorability index of 134. The creative earned attention, delivered a clear message, and was remembered the next day.
Two questions to take back to your next review
If your ad was celebrated online, do you know whether it worked? If it drew little attention online, do you count it as a failure?
Social buzz answers neither question. Lay’s conversation read as flat, and two of its ads still placed in the top three of 68. Measuring what an ad did to the people who saw it answers both.
Play the game
Five matchups. Pick the ad that worked in each, then see how your instincts compare.
Prep for 2027
Read our 2027 Super Bowl Planning Guide and get the five strategic moves for brands planning their 2027 Super Bowl ad strategy, backed by 2026 ad performance data.
